Changes: Accept S00-023 recovery readiness and record independent QA evidence and handoff; preserve unfinished S00-005 storage acceptance. Validation: Inspect implementation and prior checkpoint diffs/messages; verify inventory, pins and matching hashes; repeat both node syntax checks and tasks.py validate, exit 0. No storage runtime or browser checks performed. Task: S00-023 Agent: auto-qa-2de51e85c611 Role: qa Action: review Status: done Task title: Устранить прерывание: Выбрать IndexedDB wrapper и migration policy
4.1 KiB
S00-023 independent QA review
Reviewer: auto-qa-2de51e85c611 (qa), 2026-10-15. Executor: auto-storage-e6946c6f94e3. Decision: approve recovery readiness.
Input: assigned card/packet, startup/workflow documents, required TESTING/storage/ ADR registry/blocker inputs, original handoff/run record, accepted ADR 0001, S00-002 and S00-025 executor/review evidence and handoffs. Output: independent review of the preserved-artifact restart checkpoint. This engineering remediation has no product requirements of its own.
Acceptance findings
- Recovery readiness passed. Original run.json records recovered_interruption=true, blocked S00-005 and resolver S00-023. The blocker specifically requests preserving partial artifacts, verifying them in a fresh bounded session and independent review before a new executor. RECOVERY.md supplies that inventory and precise restart steps. S00-025 independently resolved the subsequent launcher failure; both this reviewer and the executor received complete fresh inputs. The historical interruption was inspected through its persisted result, not recreated by killing a coordinator.
- Original acceptance was not bypassed. S00-005 remains blocked before this decision; missing ADR/quota outputs and defective unfinished rollback remain explicitly its work. No runtime storage success, wrapper approval or browser behavior is claimed. Static inspection confirms repeated creation of the accounts store and overwritten request handlers described by the checkpoint. These are original unfinished work, not a reason to implement S00-005 inside this recovery review.
Inspected implementation commit 30ee500054 and
prior checkpoint a971d3cf4b. Source diff adds only
experiments/0004-storage-design/RECOVERY.md. Other paths are evidence, handoff,
commit message and generated workflow state/matrices; state records only this
claim/submit. Existing code/dependency files were preserved. Executor message
accurately describes actual changes/checks and limits. Initial working tree clean.
No acceptance defect or review blocker found.
Independent checks
- python3 scripts/tasks.py resume --agent auto-qa-2de51e85c611: exit 0, [] expected for reviewer; show S00-023 and packet S00-023 --agent auto-qa-2de51e85c611: exit 0 each. No claim; distinct executor; prerequisites done.
- Read-only git log/show/status and required artifact reads: passed. Initial guessed ADR filename 0001-web-stack.md was absent (cat exit 1); dependency evidence located existing 0001-stack.md, read successfully. No required input missing.
- Inline Python manifest/lock/inventory assertions: exit 0. Six preserved files read and hashed; fake-indexeddb 6.2.5, Node 24.21.0/npm 11.19.0 pins agree; lock license, HTTPS registry/SHA512 integrity, strict TLS and missing outputs verified. Lock SHA256 4811ff344287daa6d2e0c01c6fb0a2f1f81021a157a833f9e8533c22e40b5d91; rollback 981516d6fcddeccef996c7520ab7c34bebb6b1af931653678714e9f149ef5dc9; probe 80ad5b9705f7ea9ee380d2ca9cc6c89bb86fddf81118535e6eb1136085c9cbba. All three match executor evidence; historical interruption assertions also passed.
- node --version: exit 0, v24.1.0 (host, not selected execution pin). node --check experiments/0004-storage-design/src/rollback.mjs and node --check experiments/0004-storage-design/src/_probe.mjs: exit 0 each. These are syntax checks only, not execution with the selected runtime.
- python3 scripts/tasks.py validate: exit 0, 296 tasks, revision 111.
- git diff --check: exit 0. Final review metadata scope/whitespace checked before terminal transition; reviewer authors only this report, handoff note and message.
No npm install, storage runtime, migration/rollback/quota/restart, browser/server, new model or nested sandbox check was performed. Dependency execution results were read as previously accepted evidence, not rerun. Approval permits only the next fresh S00-005 executor after coordinator commit; it does not accept a storage design. Coordinator owns Git and next process. Reviewer exits immediately after approve.