wt
b6691d9c8b
Changes: Accept S00-013 with an independent QA report and review handoff; no source edits. Confirm exact packets and mandatory supplementary reads remain available within the unchanged prompt budget. Validation: make check passed all 68 tests, including UTF-8 stdin/EOF, timeout and terminal-transition regressions. Independently checked all 556 prompts: maximum 77693 characters; S21-006 retains 26 exact UI sections. Root escape and oversized-budget rejection checks passed; git diff --check passed. No application or parent-task acceptance claimed. Task: S00-013 Agent: auto-qa-869b22acd478 Role: qa Action: review Status: done Task title: Bound oversized S21-006 runner context without truncating requirements
3.5 KiB
S00-013 independent QA review
Reviewer: auto-qa-869b22acd478 (qa). Executor: auto-ci-cd-5f68f03dd33b (ci-cd). Date: 2026-10-15. Decision: approve the bounded prompt-context remediation.
Input: assigned card/context packet, NFR-007, startup/workflow instructions, blocker reports, executor evidence/handoff/message, accepted ADR 0000 and S00-001/S00-011 dependency evidence/reviews/handoffs. Output: this independent acceptance report. No source changes by reviewer.
Findings against acceptance
- Independently enumerated claim and review prompts for all 278 tasks: 556 prompts fit the unchanged default 80000-character budget. Maximum is S21-006 review, 77693; claim is 77669 (agent auto-preview).
- Every enumerated prompt contains its whole exact context packet. The focused S21-006 regression passes for both actions and checks each verbatim UI Kit section (26 sections), all input references and fresh-session/exit instructions. Supplementary documents are mandatory project reads before implementation/review, with explicit missing-artifact blocker guidance. They remain available by path; their contents are not silently truncated. Startup instructions, previous handoff and reviewer executor evidence stay inline. No specs, packet generation, contracts, dependencies or budget validation changed.
- Independent make check passed all 68 tests, including delayed large UTF-8 stdin/EOF delivery, timeout and terminal-transition process stopping. The executor source diff does not modify stdin transport or lifecycle code.
Examined executor commit b1014f36c9, its message, both source patches and workflow/generated metadata. Source scope is scripts/runner.py and tests/tooling/test_automation.py only; other changes record claim/submit and task artifacts. Executor message accurately describes the actual implementation and checks. Initial working tree was clean. No acceptance defect or review blocker found.
Actual independent commands and results
python3 scripts/tasks.py resume --agent auto-qa-869b22acd478: exit 0, empty owned list as expected for reviewer; no claim.python3 scripts/tasks.py show S00-013andpacket S00-013 --agent auto-qa-869b22acd478: exit 0 each; assigned review scope/state and exact NFR-007 read.git log --all --grep='^S00-013:' --oneline,git show b1014f3with scoped source/metadata sections, andgit status --short: exit 0; patch/message inspected and initial tree clean.make check: exit 0; validation reports 278 tasks, 22 stages, 221 requirements, 211 allocated Web requirements, revision 16. All 68 tests passed in 17.000s on Python 3.9.6.- Read-only Python enumeration using Runner(default config): exit 0; all 556 full packets preserved and prompt lengths <=80000, with maximum and S21-006 values above.
- Read-only Python checks with an in-memory task input
../outside-required.mdand a Runner budget of 48000: exit 0; asserted project-root escape rejection and explicit oversized-prompt failure. No files changed. git diff --check: exit 0.
Limits and handoff
Approval covers foundation prompt preparation only. Agents must read the explicitly referenced project artifacts; inclusion of paths is not proof of reading them. Future larger handoffs/evidence remain subject to fail-fast budgets. No browser/server/application readiness or S00-002 acceptance is claimed. S00-012 must continue in a new coordinator-selected process after the review commit; reviewer does not implement or accept that parent task. Coordinator owns Git commit and next fresh session.