wt
6ac04950bf
Changes: Accept bounded S00-025 launcher remediation; record independent QA evidence and handoff without accepting parent storage work. Validation: Reproduced conflicting arguments with expected exit 2; active argv help and Codex 0.159.0 checks exit 0; tasks.py validate and git diff --check pass. Inspected executor diff/message and accepted dependency evidence. No model, browser, sandbox or storage test rerun. Task: S00-025 Agent: auto-qa-27d3befe5097 Role: qa Action: review Status: done Task title: Устранить прерывание: Устранить прерывание: Выбрать IndexedDB wrapper и migration policy
4.0 KiB
S00-025 independent QA review
Reviewer: auto-qa-27d3befe5097 (qa), 2026-10-15. Executor: auto-storage-8b47cee148df. Decision: approve.
Input: assigned card/packet, mandatory startup/task inputs, previous handoff, blocker reports, original failed runner log, accepted ADR 0001 and direct S00-002/S00-028 evidence, reviews and handoffs. Output: independent acceptance of the bounded launcher interruption remediation. No product requirement applies to this engineering card.
Findings and acceptance
Inspected implementation commit 43610f3356 and
previous S00-025 checkpoint 3fd75a818f.
Executor message accurately describes actual changes/checks and limitations.
Implementation changes only evidence, handoff, commit message and CLI-generated
state/matrices. No storage source, ADR, configuration or immutable spec changed.
The state diff only records S00-025 claim/submit; initial reviewer tree was clean.
Acceptance 1 passed: original S00-023 log identifies the mutually exclusive approval/sandbox arguments, reproduced independently with child exit 2. Active argv exactly matches reviewed S00-028 and parses with exit 0. No new source fix is necessary: S00-028 already resolved the launcher problem. This fresh reviewer received complete inputs, as did the executor. Accepted S00-028 review records independent project-write/outside-denial sandbox verification; that diagnostic was inspected, not rerun or claimed as a new test here.
Acceptance 2 passed: S00-023 and S00-005 remain blocked before this transition; no storage artifacts were modified or original storage work executed. Approving S00-025 permits a fresh S00-023 recovery session; it does not accept S00-005 or ADR 0004. No defect or review blocker found.
Independent checks and actual exits
- python3 scripts/tasks.py resume --agent auto-qa-27d3befe5097: exit 0, [] as expected for a reviewer; no claim. show S00-025 and packet S00-025 --agent auto-qa-27d3befe5097: exit 0 each, distinct executor and done dependencies.
- Read-only git log/show/status and required artifact reads: exit 0; inspected current implementation and prior checkpoint, original run.json/output.log.
- Python subprocess.run(['codex','exec','--approve-for-me','--sandbox', 'workspace-write','-'], input='', capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=20): child exit 2 with "cannot be used with '--sandbox" diagnostic. Assertion passed. Read-only PATH alias warning also present; parser rejects before model execution.
- Python JSON assertions: runner.local.json argv exactly ['codex','-c','sandbox_workspace_write.network_access=true','exec', '--approve-for-me','--ephemeral','-']; commands_by_role empty. No config edit. subprocess.run(argv+['--help'], input='', capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=20): child exit 0, help states using the workspace-write sandbox.
- codex --version via same timeout20 subprocess: exit 0, codex-cli 0.159.0. Combined assertions wrapper exit 0, including S00-002/S00-028 done, S00-025 review and both parents blocked. No --help in the negative test.
- python3 scripts/tasks.py validate: exit 0, 296 tasks, revision 108.
- git diff --check: exit 0 before review metadata. Final metadata whitespace and scope check performed before terminal transition.
OpenAI Docs skill used. Official CLI reference searched and opened on 2026-10-15; documents the conflicting flags and workspace-write behavior. Exact local results establish behavior of installed 0.159.0.
Limits: help is a parser check, not inference/authentication success. No additional model, nested sandbox, browser, server, IndexedDB migration/rollback/quota or app readiness test performed. Dependency build/sandbox results were inspected as previously accepted evidence, not repeated. No source changes by reviewer. Coordinator owns commit and the next fresh session; done without coordinator commit does not complete the automation cycle. Reviewer exits after approve.